
Mario is at the photography group for the first time. The door is open. Inside, people sit around a table, laughing about something whose beginning he missed. For a moment, that feels like the condition for entry: you would have to know the story already.
In our fictional scene, Mario has brought a camera. It gives his hands something to do. He pauses briefly at the entrance. A woman looks up and points to an empty chair. He says his name and sits down, cautiously enough that the chair might reconsider his membership.
Photos lie on the table. One picture shows a blurry dog. Mario says his best dog pictures mostly show the spot where the dog was a moment ago. The woman laughs. He laughs too. A conversation begins.
On the way home, though, what he remembers especially well is his little pause before that sentence. Was he quiet for too long? Did he talk too much about the camera? Perhaps the laughter was merely polite. From inside, the evening was surprisingly rich in passages that could use another edit.
We hear the conversation and our own commentary on it.
Mario knows his unspoken doubts. The others do not know them in the same way. They met a new participant who asked a question and told a little story. Mario still does not know whether they liked it.
The liking gap refers to a gap observed in studies: after conversations with new acquaintances, people on average underestimate how much their conversation partner likes them. This is a statement about estimates and feedback, not an ability to read minds.
In our scene, the friendly gesture toward the chair, a laugh, and Mario's later rumination sit side by side. They do not yet add up to a complete judgment of the group. And social connectedness is more than a successful first conversation.
The first impression can be friendlier than expected.
Across several studies, Boothby and colleagues compared assumed liking with conversation partners' reports. Underestimation appeared in different first-meeting situations, including in the laboratory and among new roommates. Studies [25]
The finding is an average pattern from the encounters studied. It promises neither approval from every person nor admission to every group. Our visit to the photography club is a fictional adaptation, not a situation that was studied. What is interesting is the difference between our own inner commentary and the impression others actually report.
Next time, there is already a beginning.
A week later, Mario returns. The woman at the table asks whether he has brought a dog picture with a dog in it this time. He has to laugh. That little remark had stayed with someone, while what he mainly took home was the pause before it.
He sits down. The group is still new to him. But now he knows a story whose beginning he did not miss. His camera can go on the table. His hands now know what to do without it.
Sources: Boothby et al. (2018) [25]. Reviewed by the editors on November 6, 2026; not independently reviewed by subject-matter experts.