
Mara has already greeted Ruth three times in her head. In one version, things turned chilly; in another, uncomfortably quiet. In the third, Mara explained very reasonably why their last phone call had gone so wrong. Unfortunately, Ruth said only the lines Mara had assigned her.
Now she waits in the garden café. Two cups stand on the table. She ordered Ruth's coffee too, just as she used to. Yellow leaves lie beneath the chairs. Mara smooths her jacket and looks toward the entrance.
There is Ruth. She holds her bag strap and smiles cautiously. Mara pulls out a chair. Her rehearsed sentence is ready. “Are you sitting in the draft on purpose?” Ruth asks.
That appeared in none of the versions. Mara looks at the napkin, which is currently traveling across the table. The café has an opinion of its own about the staging. This encounter and its characters are fictional.
A rehearsal knows only part of the cast
Our expectations can anticipate an encounter. In prospection, we imagine possible future situations. Many details are still missing: the other person's actual words, how they feel that day, the surroundings, and our own response in the moment.
Mara knows why the reunion matters to her. She does not know what Ruth will say. Her inner scene fills this gap with one possibility. Because the possibility can be told coherently, it quickly feels like a finished script.
Another prediction joins it: how will I feel, and for how long? Imagination does not already contain that complete answer either. A real encounter can be friendlier, harder, or simply different. The story has to leave room for that.
How long will a feeling stay?
In several studies in 1998, Daniel Gilbert and colleagues examined predictions about later feelings. In one laboratory study, female students experienced a staged rejection from a paid product test. Of 91 participants, 78 were included in the analysis. Those who had estimated their feelings beforehand reported, on average, less negative feelings after the rejection than they had expected.
The study examined an artificial rejection and short periods of time, not a reunion in a café. It provides an example of how expected and reported feelings can differ. This means neither that our worries are always exaggerated nor that a real encounter will generally turn out better.
A sentence nobody had predicted
They move to a more sheltered table. Ruth looks at the cup. “Thanks. I mostly drink tea now.” Mara has to laugh. Even the coffee knew less about the future than she had thought.
Then it becomes quiet. Ruth says the last phone call hurt her. Mara nods. This part is not easy, even now. She begins to explain, pauses, and asks instead, “How did it come across to you?”
Ruth answers. Mara hears something she had included in none of her inner versions. The conversation is not settled yet. But it now has two voices. Beside the table, the wind lifts a leaf and sets it down again.
Sources: Predicted and experienced feelings [63]. Reviewed by the editors on November 7, 2026; not independently reviewed by subject-matter experts.