Story / Fear & Imagination

The movie is over.
The image is still there.

Why can a thought return just when we want to get rid of it?

Your reading pathFear & Imagination
The fictional Emil stands with a toothbrush at the sink in a warmly lit bathroom, looking tensely through the open door into the blue hallway.
Only Emil is in the bathroom. The movie finds room there anyway.AI-generated illustration: Mario & Aik
On this page

The credits ended long ago. Emil stands in the bathroom, brushing his teeth. Everything is as usual: the towel, the plant, the soap. Only the open door has a surprising presence today.

The movie featured a similar door. At first, nothing behind it. Then something Emil would very much rather not have beside his bathroom right now. “Please don't think about it,” he tells himself. Immediately, he remembers what he did not want to think about.

He looks at the toothpaste tube. Mint. Very good. There is little to object to about mint. Then he checks whether the movie scene has finally gone. Unfortunately, to carry out this check, he has to bring it to mind again.

No sound comes from the hallway. Emil looks over anyway, toothbrush in his mouth. If anyone were there, they would first have to wait until Emil had rinsed. This story and its character are entirely fictional.

Pushing a thought away also engages with it

Thought suppression refers to the deliberate attempt to keep a particular thought out of mind. Emil's scene adds a small loop: he wants to check whether it is working. In doing so, he engages with the very same image again.

An inner image is part of mental imagery. Emil knows that he watched a movie. This knowledge and his uneasy feeling can exist side by side. The familiar hallway does not thereby become evidence that the movie's plot is continuing.

The story describes a possible aftereffect of fiction. Not every horror movie lingers this way, and not every unwanted thought grows stronger when pushed away. How long something lingers emerges only in each person's everyday life.

The famous white bear

In a 1987 experiment, Daniel Wegner and colleagues had 34 students say their thoughts aloud. Initially, they were asked either not to think about a white bear or to allow thoughts about it. Later, the task changed. Those who had previously suppressed the thought reported more bear thoughts in the following thinking period than the comparison group did in its first thinking period.

This later increase is called a rebound. The experiment lasted only a few minutes and used a neutral target thought. It did not examine nighttime movie scenes. The result therefore points to a possible difficulty in controlling thoughts, not a rule that every suppressed thought must immediately return more strongly.

The hallway stays a hallway

Emil rinses. As he puts the toothpaste down, its cap falls into the sink. A small, entirely uncinematic incident. He picks it up and wipes the wet edge.

When he goes into the bedroom, the movie image has not quite disappeared. This annoys him for a moment. Then he looks for the charging cable, which has slipped behind the nightstand again. So the evening still has a few surprises planned after all.

As he turns off the light, he looks into the hallway one last time. His towel is hanging there.

Sources: Thought suppression and later rebound [62]. Reviewed by the editors on November 7, 2026; not independently reviewed by subject-matter experts.

Continue along the reading path · Fear & Imagination

It Was Different in My Mind

Mara has played an encounter through in her mind several times. Now a real person answers.